Welcome to Lefty's Pizzeria and Restaurant
Lefty's Pizzeria and Restaurant, located at 391 Crooks Ave, Paterson, NJ, is a beloved culinary gem specializing in authentic Italian cuisine. Celebrated for its Grandma Pie, lefty’s consistently garners rave reviews for its delicious pizza and expansive menu that includes mouthwatering pasta and subs. The vibrant atmosphere is perfect for both quick slices and family dinners, with attentive staff ensuring a welcoming experience. Notable dishes include chicken penne, vodka pasta, and their renowned Tiramisu. Customers appreciate the restaurant's commitment to quality and service, making Lefty's a top choice for pizza lovers and Italian food enthusiasts alike.
-
391 Crooks Ave, Paterson, NJ 07503, United States Hotline: +1 973-998-9055
Welcome to Lefty's Pizzeria and Restaurant, a cherished dining destination nestled in Paterson, New Jersey. Located conveniently at 391 Crooks Avenue, this establishment has earned a reputation for excellence that spans decades. With its bustling kitchen and welcoming atmosphere, Lefty's is a sanctuary for pizza lovers and Italian cuisine enthusiasts alike.
As soon as you step inside, you’re greeted by the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizzas and homemade Italian dishes. The spacious layout caters to both those looking for a quick slice on the go and families seeking a cozy evening meal. Numerous customer reviews highlight the standout Grandma Pie, which has been touted as the best in the region. Its crispy, flavorful crust and delightful toppings have set a benchmark that keeps patrons returning for more.
Lefty’s excels not just in pizza, but also in its diverse menu featuring classic Italian dishes. From tantalizing pastas like the spaghetti bolognese to hearty sandwiches, every item reflects a commitment to quality. Regular diners rave about the chicken cutlets, noting how they achieve a perfect balance of flavor and texture. Desserts, such as the Tiramisu, are must-tries that round out a fulfilling meal.
Exceptional service enhances the dining experience at Lefty’s. Clients frequently mention how friendly and attentive the staff is, making sure every visit is enjoyable. The personal touch, from remembering returning customers' preferences to ensuring timely delivery, creates a feeling of community and belonging.
Overall, Lefty’s Pizzeria and Restaurant stands out not just for its exceptional food, but also for the warm, welcoming atmosphere that invites you to return time and again. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch, a celebratory dinner, or catering for a special occasion, Lefty’s delivers a taste of Italy that is both satisfying and memorable. Don’t just take our word for it; stop by and experience the magic at Lefty's yourself!
Back with another BYOB review. I'm sure you haven't had a better Grandma Pie! I promise you. Lefty's for decades has been a top 2 pizza spot for Grandma Pies, in my opinion, and today they are clear at #1. A first today was my dine-in experience. Spacious place you can grab a quick slice to-go, also decent amount of tables you can sit down and enjoy a nice dinner with the family. They also offer a full arrange of Italian dishes that smelled great coming out of their busy Friday night kitchen. But we came for the Grandma Pie, and well, it's never a disappointment.
I recently ordered catering for my son’s birthday party, and they delivered everything on time and piping hot. We got a variety of stuff. Pizzas, pasta, and subs. My wife had a spaghetti bolognese (She loved it. She’s picky so her approval does not come easy) Had to share that everyone at the party raved about the food. They even included extra plates and napkins without me asking. Fantastic service and the delivery driver was very attentive. She helped carry the trays in and wished my son a happy birthay. I'll definitely be ordering again.
Delicious pizza and Tiramisu. Can't wait to check other meals.
Best pizza in town? Honey, best pizza of my life. That's coming from a born and raised Jersey girl. Shout out to the man in the back that makes my tri color grandma's pie PERFECT every time, without fail. My stomach loves you
I went there Saturday night crazy busy, which makes sense because the food was great. I had a good chicken penne, vodka pasta with a slice of margarita pizza want to mention that the staff absolutely phenomenal seeing how stressful their environment was but yet still delivering the high expectation it's being super friendly. I love the hostess Elvera she was so sweet.
Refered to this place after complaining there were no good places to eat to a friend. Honesty been eating here once a week since my initial visit. This place has set the standard for Italian. I'm going again today, second day in a row. Best sandwich's around. Have almost tried them all. Entrees are equally as good. Can't wait to try the pizza. Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Lefty’s is my new go-to. Their chicken cutlets are near perfect. The team is super friendly and makes you feel right at home. Elvira took my order last time. Lovely people in there!
First time customer here. Picked up 2 pies Monday night, regular and one with vegetables. I ordered it crispy and thin. The lady at the counter remembered me when I came to pick up my order and made sure I liked how it was made. I asked for a hot sauce and they quickly brought it. This place is booming and the pizza is fantastic, it exceeded my expectations. I had no idea that all their meats are non pork products and will definitely be back ordering a pepperoni or sausage pie. Their pizza is fantastic and so is the staff.